Are you a contractor? Get pricing for your next job. Request a quoteResources & Guides  |  Contact Us

5-Inch vs 6-Inch Gutters: Which Should You Install?

By Gutter Supply Chicago

Choosing between 5-inch and 6-inch gutters comes down to roof size, roof pitch and how much water the gutter has to carry. This guide explains the difference so you can pick the right size for each job in Chicago.

5 inch vs 6 inch gutters K-style profile

Quick answer

Use 5-inch K-style gutters for most average-size homes. Choose 6-inch gutters for large or steep roofs, long runs, roofs with valleys that dump water in one spot, and commercial buildings. A 6-inch gutter carries noticeably more water and is usually paired with larger 3x4 downspouts.

5-Inch vs 6-Inch Gutters at a Glance

5-Inch K-Style6-Inch K-Style
Typical useMost single-family homesLarge, steep or complex roofs and commercial jobs
Water capacityStandardHigher
Common downspout2x3 inch3x4 inch
LookSmaller profileLarger profile, more visible
Material costLowerHigher

How Roof Size and Pitch Change the Answer

The more roof area that drains into a gutter, the more water it has to carry. Steep roofs push water faster, and valleys can concentrate it in one corner. On those jobs a 5-inch gutter can overflow during heavy Chicago storms, even if the home is not especially large.

Do Not Forget the Downspouts

The downspout is often the real bottleneck. A 6-inch gutter with small downspouts will still overflow. Pair 6-inch gutters with 3x4 inch downspouts and plan enough outlets for the roof area. Order matching end caps and elbows for the size you choose.

Hangers and Snow Load

A larger gutter holds more water, snow and ice, which means more weight. Use sturdy hangers with closer spacing on 6-inch runs, and consider a heavier coil gauge. Our gutter coil gauge guide explains the options.

Ordering Either Size in Chicago

Gutter Supply Chicago supplies aluminum gutter coil and gutters for both sizes, with job-site delivery across our service area. Request a quote or call (312) 823-7355 to confirm sizes in stock.

For roofing and drainage best practices, see the National Roofing Contractors Association.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are 6-inch gutters better than 5-inch?

Not always. 6-inch gutters carry more water, so they are better for large or steep roofs. For an average home, 5-inch gutters are usually enough and cost less.

What size downspout goes with 6-inch gutters?

6-inch gutters are usually paired with 3x4 inch downspouts. 5-inch gutters usually use 2x3 inch downspouts.

Can I mix 5-inch and 6-inch gutters on one house?

Yes. Some contractors use 6-inch gutters only on the sections that drain the largest roof areas, and 5-inch gutters elsewhere.

Where can I buy 5-inch and 6-inch gutter supplies in Chicago?

Gutter Supply Chicago supplies both sizes with same-day quotes and job-site delivery. Call (312) 823-7355.

Ready to Order for Your Next Job?

Send your list and get a same-day quote with job-site delivery.

Request a Quote   Call (312) 823-7355